just think about it for a second, do you realize how unnatural it would have been that after 6 years of no answers they just answer EVERYTHING in the finale? It would have been extremely awkward for the writers, and the viewers. heres how a scene would have gone The Tree had just fallen on Ben. Sawyer: Don't worry bug eyes, we'll get you out. Hurley: Hey Ben, Who Was in the cabin? Ben Exposits for 30 minutes.