Jack's story doesn't add up

Took July 5, 2009 User blog:Took

is it just me, or did the writers for Lost completely butcher the story that Jack told Kate in the Pilot part 1? in that episode, Jack made it seem like he cut the girl's whatever sac, which would make her paralyzed. he said he felt extreme fear, and the only way he conquered it and sowed her back up was by counting to 5, and letting the fear in. then he didnt feel any fear, and got the job done. when the writers decided to show us this story in the finale for season 5, it turns out Jacks dad was involved, something Jack left out in the Pilot. turns out christian put jack in a time-out. this turned out to be such a dissapointment for me, and seems like the writers couldve done a better job with that scene. thoughts?

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki