Were they dead the whole time?

I know some people think that everyone on the island was dead the whole time but it doesn't make sense: How did they get off the island if they were dead? How do we explain what the island was? Christian said that everything that happened to them was real, wouldn't that mean that they were alive? Just wondering! thanks! <3

( I want you guys to know that I don't actually think they were dead throughout the series I just wanted to see your responses so it can be cleared up for other people....including my friends and family who don't believe me) --TheOther108 03:52, January 13, 2011 (UTC)

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki