It seems to have become a fairly widespread and often mentioned assumption/prediction that Richard arrived on the island on the Black Rock... but I've never read a single argument to explain where this theory came from?
Personally I think it's a perfectly reasonable guess but no more than that - the fact that it is such a widely held opinion makes me think I missed something along the way, in which case can someone help me out!?
Where's the 'evidence' for the theory - is it just that he's really old and the Black Rock's really old??? That can't be all the reasoning surely...
Thanks to anyone who can settle this for me!Read more >
I just rewatched Par Avion where Mikhail tells Locke, Sayid and Kate that they're not on Jacob's list, and remembering that in I Do Danny mentions Jack not being on the list also, it struck me that all 4 of these people were actually visited by Jacob in the real world in The Incident.
I don't really have a theory on this, just thought I'd throw it out there... anyone have any thoughts?Read more >