So Charlie was my favorite character for the first 3 seasons of Lost but one thing that really annoyed me was that his final two wishes were never fulfilled. Desmond never gave Claire Charlie's list and Sun never gave her his DS ring. Ok granted the list was probably destroyed in Desmond's swim to and from The Looking Glass. But for the ring there was a perfect opportunity in the Hydra cages when Sun gave Jin his wedding ring back, it could have reminded her of the DS ring and she could have given it to Claire then. Ive no clue was the writers left out that final bit of Charlies story. Was anyone else disappointed by that?