OK, some people say that Desmond lied to Charlie so he could be with Penny. Maybe I'm biased (look at my picture), but I don't think he did. He had a flash of Charlie getting struck by lightning, but that DIDN'T happen because something changed. Desmond even offered to swim down to the looking glass himself, and he would of if Charlie had not bonked his head. Let's take a vote, who think he lied, who thinks he didn't?
He didn't lie - 11 votes
He did lie - 7 votes