is Christian the Monster?

Mirth23 February 5, 2010 User blog:Mirth23

For the longest time I was sure that Christian was some kind of ghost of himself who had a special awareness of things on the Island. Even when we discovered the Monster could manifest as dead humans, Christian seemed different. Most other appearances like Yemi were a one-off for the person who cared about them, whereas Christian's body had disappeared and he appeared to many different 815ers.

With the confirmation that MIB/Flocke and the Monster are one and the same, now I'm not so sure. What do you think?

pros for Christian IS the Monster:

  • Christian played a direct role in guiding Locke to turn the wheel and get himself killed, which seemed to be part of the Monster's plan.
  • Christian directed Frank and Sun to wait for Flocke for guidance, sort of like how Alex told Ben to follow Flocke's orders.
  • Many walking/talking/touching dead people on the Island turn out to be the Monster (one exception is Hurley's ghosts).
  • There seem to be hints, like the smoke detector going off.

cons for Christian is NOT the Monster:

  • The cabin appeared to be surrounded by ash the first two times we saw Christian in it.
  • Christian's body vanished while Locke's was still there.
  • Aside from Hurley's ghosts, a couple others don't necessarily seem to be the Monster. For example, Horace and Ben's mother. Also, Claire (assuming she's dead).
  • Christian was with Frank and Sun while Flocke was with Ben. Smokey has seemed limited to one body at a time.
  • Christian's interest in Claire and in having people say hi to Jack for him seemed more fatherly than Monsterly.

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki