Here is my first, and likely only, Lost Blog on my new favorite theory…
Penny is Annie.
It began as a passing thought, but then led to some bigger ideas that might just hold some water.
When I first came across the Penny = Annie theory, I began to mull it over and it eventually led to one decision: Penny had to have been on the island at the same time as Ben. All of the math works out to this…Widmore and Ben were on the island at the same time. Ben and Penny are not drastically different in age, even if there is a ten year difference; it is likely that Ben did not oust Widmore until he was at the very least in his teens somewhere. Now I know that time works differently on the island, which could make Ben considerably older than Penny, but u…Read more >