Try this one on for size

Smoke Monster/Nemesis/UnLocke/Dead-Christian/Apparitions of dead people are a Genie and the Island is its Lamp. Jacob is controlling it by force and it wants its freedom back. I know I have said this before but I cannot get it out of my mind as a possibility. Don't Genies appear as smoke at first before they take physical form of some sort???

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki