I still can't figure this one out. A lot of people are arguing that MIB is good and that Jacob is the bad one. The only reason anyone is saying this is that in the last few episodes they have made MIB appear more human by actually having emotions. Let us not forget that MIB (as the smoke monster) killed many people on the island, including the pilot, Mr. Eko, and attacked almost everyone else on the island. The only argument I can see to counter me is maybe some people could say Jacob killed more people just to bring certain ones to the island (For instance, all the people that died when the plane crashed). I won't argue that MIB is becoming more human and maybe someone we can relate to at times, but I still need to hear some arguments as to why MIB could even be considered good?