This episode had a lot of ups and downs for me. The pros: It was nice to see Libby again. It was interesting to see Libby and Hurley connect to their other timeline. The cons: The way that Ilana died was horrible. What's up with that? I also did not like the way that Michael explained the whispers. The whispers have been a huge mystery throughout the series and the explanation behind them was...lame. Also, wondering why Desmond ran over Locke. Any comments appreciated.