After The Candidate, is it reasonable to assume Widmore, unbeknownst to most of his group, is actually carrying out MIB's orders? Besides last season's clues that Widmore wanted Locke on the island, and that Bram said Widmore was the wrong side, there have been some clues of it this season. For example, Flocke knew the C4 was on the plane before he even went in, since he took the watch to use for the bomb. Then, why would Charles leave the sub so unguarded? Is it a coincidence the guy in the tree only shot Kate after MIB was in the water? If she wouldn't have been shot Jack wouldn't have gotten in the sub, bringing the bomb with him. And I think this plan was made when MIB was missing at the beginning of the episode. I think Widmore captur…Read more >
This is mostly taken from comments I've posted other blogs but would like others to think about it. Many times now I've posted on blogs arguing that Christian was in fact MIB. My arguments were as follows.
"I think it was MIB, in several circumstances. Really the only times I am certain it wasn't was when he appeared to Jack off island. But I think that was explained simply enough by the fact that real ghost Charlie said a real ghost would come see Jack (Christian). As far as on island, look at the facts.
He appeared directly after the coffin of Christian's landed on island, exactly the same scenario of when MIB took Locke's form.
Some people use the missing body as an argument, however I think everyone agrees MIB appeared as Yemi whose body …Read more >