Seems to me that the only way it makes real sense is if they all died when the plane(Oceanic 815) crashed. The rest was just Jack working his way to redemption. The island was and is purgatory and all the characters (background stories and all) were planted in Jack's mind by some higher power to give him his shot at finding his way to Heaven. After all most of the time we are seeing things from his perspective. Funny how Locke told him "You don't have a son, Jack". Even at the end, his is dying in the bamboo field, it was really him dying after the initial crash. Anyway, it was a highly entertaining show. `Nuff said.
Goodguyswearblack 08:00, May 25, 2010 (UTC)