• Dthiessen

    In the season 4 finale right before the bomb on the freighter blows up Christian Shephard appears to Michael and says "you can go now" presumably because the island was done with him and he could now die in peace. But in "Everybody Loves Hugo" michael, or at least Michael's soul, is still trapped on the island. It seems like a contradiction for Christian to tell him he can go, and then for him to still be a trapped, tortured soul on the island.

    Read more >