Talk:Rose Nadler

From Lostpedia

She is one of them.

Me too. --skks 12:44, 24 March 2006 (PST)

Nov. 21 is a Scorpio, not a Libra

You are right, my bad, have corrected.--Tricksterson 10:17, 11 April 2006 (PDT)

Contents 1 Rose is healed 2 Rose is special 3 Rose and the Monster's sounds 4 Not what healed her.... WHO healed her? 5 Last Name 6 Returning? 7 Daughter? 8 Flashback 9 Unanswered Question 10 Plot Goof - The Wedding Ring? 11 Monster and Rose 12 Hair 13 Which Status? 14 Not a main character?

Rose is healed

Do you think that because of the magnetic field, that is what may have curred Rose's illness. Kind of like a sort of radiation

Rose is special

Alpert tells Locke that Ben is worried that the Others will believe Locke is special. As Rose was also healed by the island, Rose will become equally important to Ben and the Others.

• By not appearing in Season 3 until the last two episodes, this has been set up through Locke and Ben's interaction. A Podcast revealed that Rose and Bernard will have a major storyline, which would suggest a greater presence in season 4.
• Only Rose, Walt, Michael, and the Others know Locke was paralyzed before the plane crash.
• Only Rose, Bernard, and Locke do not want to be rescued.MixMasterMike 20:05, 8 May 2007 (PDT)MixMasterMike

Rose and the Monster's sounds

I'd like to change a reference in this article. I don't think Rose said that the monster's sounds reminded her of the Bronx. Here's a transcript of that part of the first episode:

REDSHIRT: It didn't sound like an animal, not exactly.

ROSE: That sound that it made, I keep thinking that there was something really familiar about it.

REDSHIRT #2: Really? Where are you from?

ROSE: The Bronx.

In fact, the mechanical sounds being made by the monster at this point are the sounds of Oceanic Flight 815 crashing. In the first episode, a flashback in which the plane crashes (and in which Rose figures prominently) plays immediately before this exchange, giving the viewer a great opportunity to rehear the plane sound effects. Anyone with a DVD copy of this episode can compare the monster's sounds and Oceanic Flight 815 crashing for themselves.

So I'd like to change this statement (In Pilot, Part 1, she says that the sounds made by The Monster remind of where she used to live - The Bronx, New York.) to the following:

In Pilot, Part 1, she says that the sounds made by The Monster seem really familiar.

Any objections? Boloboffin 23:49, 4 June 2006 (PDT)

One of the sounds that the monster makes is very similar to the sound made when a reciept is being printed by NYC taxi cabs. This may be why it's familiar to her since she is from the Bronx. -fontgangsta

That's exactly what it was, fontgangsta. I remember reading it somewhere. Some interview with one of the writers. Now if i can just find that interview I can prove it... --Quigley

That taxicab receipt sound also sounds like the machines that used to print lottery tickets. I wonder about any connection to Hurley or the numbers. MixMasterMike 21:43, 5 May 2007 (PDT)MixMasterMike

Not what healed her.... WHO healed her?

I am thinking Mr.eko, because when Bernard asked him if he had retrieved any african-american bodies from the water, he declined and said he would "pray for her" ... could this be the mystery behind her miraculous recovery?

• I don't know who you're because you didn't sign your post, but sorry to burst your bubble it is the island that fixed her. It has already been confirmed in the SOS episode.--CaptainInsano

Last Name

The "Lost Magazine - Issue 7" reveals Rose and Bernard's surname to be Nadler.—The preceding unsigned comment was added by Obi-Dan Kenobi (talk • contribs) .

How did we get her name to be Henderson in the first place? THE MONSTER .

Returning?

Are there any sources out there that confirm that Rose (and Bernard) are ever returning? Because I really miss Rose (and Bernard) and I'd like to see her (and him) back on the show. So can anybody find any sources that state that they're going to return any time soon? --Kbmusiclover 7:17, 9 April 2007 (PDT)

Daughter?

One of the unanswered Qs asks who her daughter is. I vaguely remember a reference to one, but I don't recall where. Can someone jog my memory? And maybe add a crossref.--TechNic|talk|conts 20:07, 18 May 2007 (PDT)

I think it was from a deleted scene. She says her daughter 'had passed'. Since it's deleted, I'm not sure that question should really be there. Blackannis 13:23, 23 May 2007 (PDT)

Flashback

Should we add a flashback characters link like the main survivors have. She did have a flashback episode. --Gluphokquen Gunih ▲ 12:02, 21 May 2007 (PDT)

• You mean the Pilot appearence. Well since the Pilot was a shared flashback for three characters, I suppose you could. Dont know?
  • The flashback was "S.O.S.".--Phil (talk) 06:53, 26 May 2007 (PDT)

Unanswered Question

"How did Rose know that the tail section people were alive?"

Surely this is a case of her 'believing' or having faith that her husband had survived? It's not some kind of mystery and we won't get an 'answer' to it, so it doesn't really belong...Liquidcow 08:56, 22 June 2007 (PDT)

Plot Goof - The Wedding Ring?

LOST is remarkably good at keeping its story sorted out considering how complex it is, but I'm a little bummed to think I've found one rather glaring problem with Rose and Bernard's story. In Walkabout, she tells Jack "Bernard's fingers always swell when we fly so finally I just decided to wear his ring on my neck", but in S.O.S. we learn they were on 815 flying back from their none-too-successful honeymoon. So...unless they did a lot of flying before their marriage, and unless Bernard had a wedding ring before they were married...you see where I'm going with this? Unless they did a lot of flying between their marriage and their honeymoon, but then it'd be weird to delay the honeymoon. Or am I missing something here? --Cyhunter 01:01, 22 February 2008 (PST)

Post-script: I did come up with one possible explaination, but it's a bit of a stretch. We know Rose lives in Brooklyn and considers New York her home. It is thus likely that when they first left for Australia, it was from the East Coast, and considering the rotation of the Earth and geography, that they would have flown eastwards over Europe, thus necessitating layovers along the way. (And although 815 was Sydney-to-LAX and thus a one-stop trip, there's no reason to assume that Rose and Bernard weren't then planning to take another plane back to the East Coast.) In this manner, it is easy to quickly become an "old hat" at flying with someone and the effects of high-altitude finger-swelling. Thus, it is not entirely unbelievable that Rose would use the phrase "His hands swell up whenever we fly...", although not so much "He started having me hold on to his wedding ring whenever we took a plane trip", which indicates multiple vacations entirely. At this point, you have to start falling back on the old "they're delirious from shock" excuse, but it'll have to do, I suppose.

One single leg of New York to stopover airport to LAX to Sydney would be sufficient for Rose to have first-hand experience Bernard's swollen hands (especially since LAX to SYD is about 13 hours one way, and they were on their return trip when the crash happened). However, another reasonable thought might be Bernard flew a lot in his life before Rose, and knew his hands swell from flying, fullstop. Add his wedding ring, and you have the pain of swollen fingers, plus the cutting off of circulation. It's not a goof, IMO. -- LOSTonthisdarnisland 10:53, 24 April 2008 (PDT)

Monster and Rose

Danflave added the UQ "Why did the the 'Monster' sound 'awfully familiar' to Rose?" My guess is it was just part of the elaborate in-joke surrounding the use of the NYC taxicab receipt printer sound effect as the Monster's "chitter". See Official Lost Podcast transcript/May 21, 2007. Robert K S (talk) 18:24, 23 April 2008 (PDT)

That's correct. Damarlton confirmed it on a podcast or audio commentary or something. --Blueeagleislander 18:48, 23 April 2008 (PDT)

Any sort of actual confirmation or citation on this? I still maintain this is an UQ. I may need to review, but I don't believe the "chitter" sound effect even played during this particular scene. Danflave 15:16, 14 May 2008 (PDT)

P.S. I read the transcript from May 21st and see no indication that Rose's comment was a conscious "in joke" related to the taxi sound. Danflave 15:20, 14 May 2008 (PDT)

Hair

Sometime between S.O.S and Greatest Hits Rose changed her hairstyle. Ok, so I'm no expert, but is it even possible to get hair like that in such a primitave standard of living. I know they had all the Dharma stuff and the pallet, but HOW do you get hair like that. I was just wondering if it was possible. User:Lostcloverfield42

The most likely explanation is the unseen red shirt, Margery did it. Cuse and Lindelof have joked about her a few times, it will probably never be answered. But if it was this would be the most likely reason. --The Whsipers 14:40, 10 August 2008 (PDT)

Which Status?

Now that the freighter exploded, on which she was supposed to be (she was taken there by Miles), which status can she take? Can we count her as dead or rather as unknown status? Gfz12 11:36, 31 May 2008 (PDT)

Good question. Even if she managed to abandon ship prior to the explosion with a life preserver on, she'd be stranded in the middle of the ocean with no nearby land, no provisions, no watercraft... Robert K S (talk) 11:51, 31 May 2008 (PDT)

• Umm you do remember her saying she was staying on the island? We never saw her on the boat in the episode nor did we see her in the last group on zodiac raft that never made it to ship due to its destruction. Her status should be alive, but her whereabouts unknown due to the island's moving. --The Cartographer 11:57, 31 May 2008 (PDT)

Not a main character?

Someone deleted my trivia item about Rose and Sawyer being the last main characters still at the camp. Is Rose not considered a main character? If Nikki and Paulo were considered main characters, then how could Rose and Bernard not be? --CurlyHairedGuy 13:12, 7 June 2008 (PDT)

Its because Nikki & Paulo were intended to have much larger parts in the Season, it was their unpopularity that meant they had premature deaths, therefore they were planned to be main stars because we'd have seen a lot more of them. Whereas Rose and Bernard were always intended to be reccurring. --The Whsipers 14:41, 10 August 2008 (PDT)