- For other uses of "?", see ? (disambiguation).
"?" (pronounced "Question Mark") is the 21st episode of Season 2 of Lost and the 46th produced hour of the series as a whole. After Eko experiences unusual dreams, he asks John to take him to the ? shown on the blast door map he saw. At the Hatch, the rest of the survivors must come to terms with what just transpired and try to ease the suffering of a mortally wounded Libby.
Previously on Lost
- A lockdown process occurs in the Hatch, causing the blast doors to drop, one crushing Locke's legs. Locke orders Henry to push the button. On the blast door jamming Locke's legs, a hidden map appears after ultra violet lights turn on. Henry tells Locke he never entered the Numbers or pressed the button and nothing happened. ("Lockdown")
- Hurley plans to take Libby on a picnic. ("Two for the Road")
- Sawyer finds that his gun is missing and realizes Ana Lucia took it. ("Two for the Road")
- Michael offers to kill Henry for Ana Lucia, but instead he kills her and Libby then frames Henry. ("Two for the Road")
Joyce telling Eko about her daughter's miracle
Mr. Eko, posing as a priest and going by the name "Father Tunde," takes confession from a man who seems to confess to adultery, but reveals he has a forged Australian passport for Mr. Eko to enter the United States. Another priest tells him the trip to the U.S. is delayed, as a miracle has happened: A woman has claimed that her child drowned in a river but was resurrected the next day. He informs Mr. Eko that he has been chosen to start an investigation of the claim. After meeting the mother, Mr. Eko tells the Monsignor he is not a good choice because he does not believe the claim. The Monsignor, however, explains that this is exactly why he was chosen.
Richard talking to Eko
Eko interviews the medical examiner about his account of the "miracle". The examiner informs a skeptical Mr. Eko that the girl was came back to life during the autopsy and provides an audiotape as supporting evidence. Eko visits the family who reported this miracle and finds a stare-eyed daughter at the porch. The mother comes out and informs him that it is not an appropriate time for him to visit. The father comes out, orders his wife and child to go back inside, and tells Eko that the whole incident was simply a misunderstanding. He claims that his wife knows that his psychic services are a fraud, that she is a fanatic and was making the claim to "spite" him.
Eko and Charlotte at the airport
Eko tells him that he will report that the incident was not a miracle. As he leaves, he sees the daughter staring at him from the window.
Mr. Eko picks up his tickets for the flight while he is at the Oceanic Airlines terminal. As he begins to walk away from the ticket desk, the girl who supposedly drowned confronts him. She informs Eko that his brother Yemi contacted her when she was "between places." She then says she knows that Eko's not really a priest, but he should have faith in himself anyway, as Yemi still does. Eko begins to angrily question the girl as to how she knows about Yemi but Libby overhears him and ask them if everything is all right. Eko shrugs it off and leaves.
On the Island
Question marks appear in the timer during Eko's dream
Eko is chopping wood with his axe on the beach, continuing to build his church. Ana Lucia appears on the beach and asks him what he is building. Eko explains that the idea of a church came from a dream. Ana Lucia responds, "A dream like this one?" Eko then notices she has a bullet hole and is bleeding from her stomach and from her mouth. She tells Eko, "You need to help John." ♪ Eko's dream travels to the Swan, where he finds his dead brother Yemi sitting at the computer. Yemi tells Eko that Locke has lost his way, and that Eko needs Locke to take him to "the question mark." He also tells him to bring the axe. The room starts to violently shake. The timer has reached the red and black tiles, but now the hieroglyphs are replaced by question marks.
Swan computer keyboard during Eko's dream
The letters on the computer keys have also been replaced with question marks. Eko wakes up hyperventilating and Charlie, sleeping nearby on the beach, turns over and asks, "What's the matter?"
Locke, Sawyer, Kate, and Jack are moving through the jungle when Michael stumbles out of the Hatch, claiming he had been shot in the arm by a person unknown to him. The group enters the Hatch and begins to investigate. Eko appears with his axe and offers his help. Sawyer and Kate discover that Ana Lucia slumped on the couch and Libby on the floor both with gunshot wounds. Kate tells Jack that Ana Lucia is dead. Libby coughs up a mouthful of blood, and Jack rushes to treat her as fear crosses Michael's face.
Ana Lucia's dead body at the Swan
Eko prays over Ana Lucia as Locke looks on. ♪ Jack insists that they go after "Henry," whom Michael says he left only half an hour earlier. Sawyer insists that Jack remain and tend to Libby's condition.
Eko offers to track down Henry Gale with Locke as he can track and they set off. Locke cannot find a trail, but Eko lies that he has found it, so Locke follows him down a random path. Locke wonders what Eko is following as he realizes that there there really is no trail. Locke prepares to head back, but Eko asks Locke to take him to the question mark. When Locke refuses, Eko headbutts him and knocks him out.
Locke showing Eko his map
When Locke later regains consciousness he shows Eko the diagram he drew from his memories of the blast door, with the question mark in the middle. Eko then tells Locke that they will go to the question mark, stating that Ana Lucia told them in his dream to find it. Locke responds with a look of skepticism. Eko asks him, "Have you ever followed a dream?" Later, as the two are arguing about symbols on the map that Locke had copied from memory, Eko steps on a Virgin Mary statue, and the two stumble into the burned plane. Eko asks what made the plane fall and Locke answers that it was "Boone who made it fall" and that his death was "a sacrifice that the Island demanded." They make camp and "wait for further instructions."
Kate telling Hurley that Libby had been shot
In the Hatch, Michael asks if Libby had said anything. Jack says that she is still unconscious and is suffering and that all he can really do is to make her more comfortable. Jack then gives Sawyer a stern look. Sawyer responds by insisting that he already gave him all of the medications. Jack clarifies that he was referring to the heroin. He asks Sawyer to fetch it and that Kate should accompany him so that she knows where Sawyer has hidden the guns. Sawyer agrees and leads Kate back to his tent. Kate learns to her surprise that he hid his belongings in a pit underneath his bed. When they leave the tent Hurley approaches them and asks if they have seen Libby. Kate tells Hurley the bad news. ♪
What Eko saw: The Pearl exterior
In a dream, Yemi appears before Eko and directs him to climb the cliff. At the top, Yemi, seated in a wheelchair, says "Wake up, John", and in terror, Eko loses his grip of the cliff and falls back to the bottom. Locke wakes from the nightmare. When he describes his dream, Eko tells him that the priest he saw was his brother, Yemi. Locke says that Yemi wanted him to follow. He then looks up the cliff from his dream, and Eko climbs the cliff. Eko struggles to the top and Locke calls to him asking if he has found anything. Eko surveys the islands verdant landscape and replies that he hasn't found anything. But as he looks down at Locke, he sees a giant question mark shaped into in the clearing's undergrowth, with the plane's tail making the period at the base of the question mark.
Locke watching the Swan from the Pearl
Eko tastes the soil and finds it was salted in the pattern of a question mark to prevent growth. Eko then picks the ground with his axe and discovers a hatch buried beneath the plane. They open the Hatch and descend. Locke finds a working light switch and they enter a room with several tables (one with cigarette debris on it) with adjustable rectangular magnifying lenses, and a series of television monitors. Locke turns them on and one shows a live surveillance feed from the Swan where Jack is seen walking past the camera. Locke sees another camera above them and also finds a pneumatic tube which proves to be functional when he inserts his map sketch and it sucks it up the tube.
Eko finds another Orientation movie on a U-matic tape. Eko and Locke watch the tape with the orientation again presented by the man in the Swan orientation tape and learn that the hatch they are in is "Station 5 - The Pearl," constructed to observe the other station(s) and to record how the subjects perform actions which they believe to be of great importance. Locke is disillusioned about his habit of entering the Numbers thinking it was just an experiment, whereas Eko's belief in its importance is heightened. He explains that they are being tested and that the reason they push the button is not because they are told to do so but because "we believe we are meant to".
The log printout from Station 5 - The Pearl
John responds in frustration and anger that he was never "meant" to do anything and that every moment of his "pathetic and useless life" is as useless as that button. Eko explains his responsibility for his brother's death, how Eko's plane crashed on the Island and how on this Island he has found the plane which took off from Nigeria, and here he found his brother and put around his neck the same cross he first wore the day he first took another man's life. So, he asks Locke, how he can say that this is meaningless and that he thinks the task at the Swan is more important than anything and that if Locke won't push the button then he will. Eko takes the log printout with him as they depart.
Hurley cries over Libby's dead body.
At the Swan, Hurley tells Michael he was going on a picnic with Libby and adds that he is glad Michael is OK. Hurley says his goodbyes, and tells her how sorry he is for having forgotten the blankets. Libby's last word is a hoarse "Michael...," which Jack misinterprets as a sign of concern for Michael. ♪ When Jack reassures Libby that Michael is fine, she appears frightened. Libby dies. ♪ While Sawyer hugs a tearful Kate, ♪ Locke and Eko make their way back to camp. Michael is sitting in the gun vault, looking solemnly down at the floor, and looks up as the alarm starts beeping.
- A majority of the events from this episode (including Libby's death) take place on Thanksgiving Day (Thursday, November 25th), 2004.
- Pierre Chang (François Chau), who gave the name "Dr. Marvin Candle" in the Swan Orientation film, calls himself "Dr. Mark Wickmund" in the Pearl Orientation video, and his left arm is no longer a prosthetic arm, which suggests that this orientation film was made before the film we see in "Orientation". This is confirmed in "He's Our You", as Radzinsky is making a model of the Swan and is surprised by Sayid's knowledge of it, even though he shows little interest in his knowledge of the Pearl and its purpose.
- This episode marks the first time in the series where one of the crash survivors refers to the Hatch by its true name (The Swan), when Eko asks Locke about the orientation of his map.
- Libby dies in this episode.
- In the dream when Eko is following Yemi up the cliff he is walking with a limp. It then turns out that Locke was the one having the dream and saw himself as Eko. Locke actually has a hairline fracture in his leg and is walking with a limp.
- This episode is rated TV-14-V.
- Although she is still listed for the rest of the season, Michelle Rodriguez (Ana Lucia) makes her final appearance as a main credited cast member.
- This is the only Eko-centric episode in which the flashback scenes are not shot with a yellow tinted lens. This is because the scenes take place in Australia, not Nigeria.
- During this episode, a brief commercial for the fictional Hanso Foundation aired amidst the normal advertisements in which the web address subLYMONal.com , part of The Lost Experience, was revealed. The website and ad were both part of an advertising campaign by Sprite (during the commercial a small tag displayed a "Paid for by Sprite" copyright).
- During the early part of Lost Season 2, there were news articles that film director Darren Aronofsky would direct an upcoming episode of the season. This episode, with its dreamy, surreal qualities perfectly suited to Aronofsky's distinct, hypnotic style, was the episode written for him. Damon Lindelof has called the episode title an ode to Aronofsky and his similarly titled movie, "π" (aka "pi"). He would later pull out of the gig, due to having just become a father.
- In one scene in the Pearl, where Locke is flicking the light switch, there is a shot of his hand but this hand actually belongs to Damon Lindelof.
- This is the sixth extended episode of Lost; it ran 5 minutes longer than the standard 1 hour episodes of Lost, other episodes that were extended were "The Other 48 Days", "What Kate Did", "The Long Con", "Maternity Leave", "Dave", "316" and "The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham".
Bloopers and continuity errors
- Michael shot Libby and Ana Lucia during daylight hours (Libby was getting blankets for a picnic) and Jack, Kate, and Locke went to get the guns from Sawyer. However, this episode has them walking the short distance back to the Swan in the dark, spending a short amount of time in the Swan, and then Sawyer and Kate are on the beach in daylight again with Hurley looking for Libby and giving the impression she had just left to get the blankets.
- During the flashback sequence where Mr. Eko is investigating the miracle at the girl's house, just as the girl is led back inside the house by the mother there is a shot of Mr. Eko which is reversed. Eko has a mole on the left side of his face, but for just this shot, the mole appears on the right side of his face, and the shadows, previously on the right are now on the left. In the next shot of Eko where he is addressing the girl's father things return to normal.
- When Sawyer approaches injured Libby, you can see that Libby's mouth and left cheek are covered with blood. Later, when Libby is shown in close-up, her mouth is clean and there's no blood at all.
- Pierre Chang does not have the prosthetic hand in the orientation film which is dated 1980. He sustained that injury in 1977 as shown in "The Incident, Parts 1 & 2" and has the prosthetic in the Swan orientation film, also from 1980. It is however possible that the Pearl orientation film was filmed before July, 1977 and was not copyrighted until 1980.
- 43 minutes into the show, when Hugo was holding Libby's hand her stomach can be seen moving as she breathes.
- When Eko sees the circle in the grass from the top of the cliff, the tail of the plane is facing the circle, pointing away from the cliff. When Eko searches for the hatch to the Pearl, the tail of the plane is now facing the cliff while the nose faces the circle (which is where Locke is standing).
|Animals • Black and white • Character connections • Children • Coincidence • Death • Deceptions and cons • Dreams • Economics • Electromagnetism • Eyes • Fate versus free will • Games • Good and bad people • Imprisonment • Isolation • Leadership • Life and death • Literary works • Mirrors • Missing body parts • Nicknames • The Numbers • Pairings • Parapsychology • Parent issues • Pregnancies • Psychology • Rain • Redemption • Relationships • Religion • Revenge • Salvation • Secrets|
- Mr. Eko is now apparently a true priest in his flashback. (Religion)
- The miracle Eko was sent to investigate had to do with a girl dying and being resurrected the following day. (Miracles) (Resurrection) (Life and death)
- Richard Malkin, the psychic Claire met in "Raised by Another" is the father of the girl Eko visited. (Character connections)
- The psychic, Richard, admits to being a fraud. (Deceptions and cons)
- Charlotte, the girl who supposedly drowned, tells Eko she met his dead brother when she was between worlds and he says he has faith in Eko. (Parapsychology)
- Eko has several dreams that lead along his venture to find the Pearl, in the dreams he is contacted by Yemi and the dreams are strangely accurate, revealing events to Eko that he could not know about, such as Ana Lucia being shot. (Dreams and visions) (Parapsychology)
- Charlotte passes on a message to Eko she receives from Yemi: "He says you were a good priest... that even though you were pretending, you're a good man." (Good and bad people)
- While Hurley, Jack, Kate, and Sawyer wait at Libby's bedside, the countdown timer displays a time of 88:00. (The Numbers)
- Sawyer calls Jack "Daniel Boone", and Ben "The Artist Formerly Known As Henry Gale". (Nicknames)
- The numbers 15, 16, and 23 can be seen on Eko's fake passport. (The Numbers)
- All of the time stamps shown in the log printout begin with 416. (The Numbers)
- Both Libby and Charlotte Malkin appeared to come "back from the dead"; however, Libby's return was short-lived and Richard Malkin explained Charlotte's resurrection scientifically. (Resurrection) (Life and death)
- Charlotte must go against her father to speak with Eko at the airport. (Parent Issues)
- During Eko's dream, the Swan timer flips over to the red and black tiles and a whirring sound is heard. (Electromagnetism)
- Libby dies from her injuries. (Life and death)
Flashes in Eko's dream
- A shot of the tailies on the beach just after the crash (from the ocean towards the beach). ("The Other 48 Days")
- The smoke coming out of the forest towards Mr. Eko. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Emma's body face down in the water. ("The Other 48 Days")
- A gold cross on a chain, lying in dirt. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Bare feet walking in the jungle with the teddy bear on a leash behind them. ("...And Found")
- Jin in a blindfold. ("The Other 48 Days")
- Rows of Heroin Marys in Nigeria. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Charlie and Mr. Eko watching the plane burn. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Mr. Eko's brother (Yemi) in his church. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Flames with the Arrow logo behind them. ("The Other 48 Days")
- Mr. Eko holding the Bible in the Arrow station. ("The Other 48 Days")
- Mr. Eko's Jesus stick with the books of the Bible carved into it. ("Fire + Water")
- Mr. Eko's hand on Goldie's jaw (when they discovered him in the jungle). ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Close shot on Locke's face (he looks surprised). ("What Kate Did")
- Very dark shot of Mr. Eko with the black smoke in the foreground. His brother's face is in the smoke. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Yemi's body, when he opens the jacket and sees him wearing the cross. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- A plane taking off. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Soldiers in a truck chasing the plane. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Yemi yelling while getting shot. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Dr. Marvin Candle from the Swan Orientation Film. ("Orientation")
- A DHARMA logo from the Swan. ("?")
| Cultural references|
(direct references only)
|Art • Automobiles • Games • History • Literary works • Movies and TV • Music • Philosophy • Religion and ideologies • Science|
- Prince. Sawyer calls Ben "The Artist Formerly Known As Henry Gale", a variation on one the many nicknames of the famous musician. (Music)
- Daniel Boone. Sawyer calls Jack "Daniel Boone", after the American pioneer and hunter whose frontier exploits made him one of the first folk heroes of the United States. (History)
|Comparative: Irony • Juxtaposition • Foreshadowing Plotting: Cliffhanger • Plot twist Stock characters: Archetype • Redshirt • Unseen character|
Story: Flashbacks • Flash-forwards • Flash sideways • Framing device • Regularly spoken phrases • Symbolism • Unreliable narrator
- After watching the orientation video, Locke describes the people in the hatch pressing the button as "rats in a maze with no cheese". In "The Constant", Daniel Faraday is seen making experiments using a rat in a maze with no cheese. (Foreshadowing)
- In Eko's dream sequence encounter with Yemi in the Swan, we see and hear the effects of not pushing the button and what precedes the Discharge for the first time. (Foreshadowing)
- In Eko's dream, Yemi tells him "What's done is done." (Regularly Spoken Phrases)
- Pushing the button is implied to be an experiment by Mark Wickmund in the Orientation film. (Plot twist)
- Both Libby and Charlotte Malkin "come back from the dead", but Libby dies shortly and Charlotte survives. (Juxtaposition)
|A-Missions • Crimes • Economics • Leadership • O-Missions • Relationships • F-Missions • Rivalries • S-Missions|
- Jack forces Sawyer to reveal the location of his gun stash. (Rivalries)
- Libby dies with Hurley at her side. (Relationships)
- Richard Malkin confesses to Eko that he is a fraud, and not really a psychic. (Crimes)
- Jack attempts to save Libby's life. (A-Missions)
- Eko sets out for the question mark under the guise of tracking "Henry," accompanied by Locke. (A-Missions)
- Eko and Locke explore the Pearl station. (A-Missions)
- Eko asks if Locke has ever followed a dream. Locke pauses, as he did once follow a dream. ("Deus Ex Machina")
- Eko tells Locke of the events back in Nigeria when the plane took off. ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Sawyer is forced to show Kate his stash of guns in order to get heroin from the Virgin Mary statues. ("The Long Con")
- Eko and Locke journey to the question mark depicted on the blastdoor map. ("Lockdown")
- Michael tells the rest of the group that it was "Henry" who shot Libby and Ana Lucia. ("Two for the Road")
- Kate quizzes Sawyer about how Ana Lucia stole his gun. ("Two for the Road")
- Hurley apologises to Libby for forgetting the blankets. ("Two for the Road")
- Eko and Locke come across the drug smuggler's plane. ("Deus Ex Machina") ("The 23rd Psalm")
- Locke says Boone was a sacrifice the Island demanded. ("Exodus, Part 2")
- The Pearl Orientation video says the Swan is an experiment. Jack asked Desmond if he ever considered this. ("Orientation")
- Sawyer calls Jack "Daniel Boone". ("The Hunting Party")