Musician/Theories

From Lostpedia

Main Article

Theories about Musician

Main Discussion

Theories may be removed if ...

Stated as questions or possibilities (avoid question marks, "Maybe", "I think", etc). More appropriate for another article. Illogical or previously disproven. Proven by canon source, and moved to main article. Speculative and lacking any evidence to support arguments. Responding to another theory (use discussion page instead). This does not include responses that can stand alone as its own theory. Usage of an indented bullet does not imply the statement is a response. See the Lostpedia theory policy for more details.

Identity

• Marvin Candle - Having defected to The Others, he may have programmed the Looking Glass code by orders from Ben.
• Dexter Stratton
• A future character, yet unseen.
• A character that is of little or no importance that will never be revealed.
  • Most likely, considering the fact that they are doing this to a lot of unseen characters.
• The monster, manifested as Brian Wilson.
• A member of Geronimo Jackson.
  • Who is Horace Goodspeed.
• Liam Pace.
  • Very unlikely as Liam was still at home when Charlie got on the plane, the code would have been set years ago.
• Charlie himself, through some form of time travel/disturbance.
  • This would explain how Charlie was able to enter the numbers flawlessly on the first try.
    • Not really, it was just a regular production choice done without purpose in mind.
• The writers may have chosen that the code would have been put by a musician so that it would stress the idea of Charlie heading towards his fate, as he is a musician himself and it would be easy for him to figure out the musical code.
• As we saw in The Shape of Things to Come, Ben is a pianist. Therefore he could have programmed the code at the same time as he stationed Bonnie and Greta. He didn't want anyone to tamper with the equipment, so as well as telling his people that the Station was flooded, he utilized the double redundancy of having a code in place, just in case anyone thought of venturing down.
• Hurley. The apparition of Charlie told Hurley to bring the guitar with him back to the Island so he could program the code.

v • d • e Theories about Redshirts and Background Characters Middle and front section survivors Seth Norris • Craig • Blonde casualty • Gas man • Scott Jackson • Steve Jenkins • Lance • Joanna Miller • N.D. Survivor • Richard • Sullivan • Woman • Gary Troup • SBSSG • Jerome • Neil "Frogurt" Tailies Emma • German tailender • Nathan • Zach • Man on beach The Others Ivan • Jason • Henrietta • Sabine • Diane • Luke • Molotov woman • Musician • Widmore's victim • Ethan's wife DHARMA Initiative Alvarez • Casey • Glenn • Mike • Paul • Tom • Wayne • Workman • Willie Kahana Redfern • Brandon • Hendricks Ajira survivors Jed

v • d • e Theories about The Others Theories in general Prominent Others Alex • Richard Alpert • Mikhail Bakunin • Juliet Burke • Eloise Hawking • Isabel • Jacob • Karl • Beatrice Klugh • Benjamin Linus • John Locke • Colleen Pickett • Danny Pickett • Ryan Pryce • Ethan Rom • Goodwin Stanhope • Harper Stanhope • Tom • Charles Widmore Minor Others Adam • Aldo • Amelia • Bonnie • Cindy Chandler • Cunningham • Diane • Emma • Erik • Greta • Henrietta • Ivan • Jason • Jill • Luke • Mattingly • Sabine • Zach Unnamed Others Ethan Rom's wife • Molotov woman • Musician • Widmore's victim Items and vehicles Ben's photo • Canteens • Fake beard • Files • Fish biscuit • Hydra television • Implant • Juliet's tape • Lists • Mikhail's document • Mystery Tales No. 40 • Richard's items • Walkie • X-ray • Galaga • Elizabeth Miscellaneous Book club • "Good People" • Lists